Your bathtub is more than just a practical fixture; it’s a centerpiece of your bathroom. Over time, fiberglass and acrylic tubs can develop stains, chips, or a dull finish, leaving the entire space looking worn. When that happens, many homeowners find themselves weighing bathtub refinishing vs. replacement. Understanding the pros and cons of each option can help you decide which one offers the right mix of style, durability, and value to bring your bathroom back to life.
Understanding Bathtub Refinishing vs. Replacement
When your tub starts looking worn, you’re left with two main choices: give it a fresh new surface or swap it out completely. Knowing what each option involves can make your decision much easier.
What Is Bathtub Refinishing?
Refinishing, sometimes called reglazing or resurfacing, is the process of repairing chips or cracks and applying a new coating to your existing tub. The result is a smooth, glossy finish that makes an old tub look almost brand new. It’s a good option if your tub is structurally sound but has cosmetic issues.
What Is Bathtub Replacement?
Bathtub replacement means removing your current bathtub entirely and installing a new one in its place. This process gives you the chance to change the size, shape, and style of the tub altogether.
Comparing the Cost of Bathtub Refinishing vs. Replacement
When weighing bathroom remodel costs, both bathtub refinishing and replacement can improve the look and function of your bathroom, but the price difference between them is significant.
Cost of Refinishing the Bathtub
On average, refinishing a bathtub costs between $300 and $800, including labor and materials. Most tub refinishing projects can be finished in a single day. This makes refinishing a bathtub a budget-friendly option for homeowners who want to refresh the look of their tub without a significant renovation.
Cost of Replacing the Bathtub
Replacing a bathtub usually starts around $1,500 and can go over $5,000, depending on the tub style and how complex the job is. A new bathtub can range from a few hundred dollars for a basic model to several thousand for high-end designs, but installation adds additional expenses. You usually have to factor in plumbing adjustments, demolition, and finishing work.
While replacing the bathtub is more expensive than refinishing the tub, a new tub often lasts longer, holds up better, and gives you more choices in design.
Pros and Cons of Refinishing a Bathtub
Understanding the benefits and limitations of refinishing your tub can help you decide whether a quick refresh is enough or if you should invest in something more long-term.
Pros of Refinishing a Bathtub
Most tub refinishing projects cost a fraction of replacement and can be completed in less than a day, with only a short curing period before the tub is ready to use again.
Refinishing is also eco-friendly since it extends the life of your existing tub and keeps large fixtures out of landfills. You can also update the color or finish of your tub with refinishing, which can help your bathroom look fresh and modern without the disruption of a complete remodel.
Cons of Refinishing a Bathtub
A refinished tub usually lasts 7 to 10 years. While a decade is a long time, it’s much shorter than the 20+ years you’d get from installing a new tub.
Refinishing can update the color or finish of your tub, but it won’t change its size, shape, or depth. So if you have an alcove bathtub and have always dreamed of a freestanding bathtub, refinishing isn’t the solution.
Perhaps the biggest issue is that refinishing won’t fix major issues like leaks, rust, or severe cracks. For example, if your bathtub feels spongy or has water damage beneath it, refinishing is only a band-aid solution. In those cases, replacement is the smarter investment.
Pros and Cons of Replacing a Bathtub
Replacing a bathtub is a bigger project, but it offers possibilities that refinishing simply can’t. Comparing the pros and cons side by side makes it easier to see if the cost of replacement matches what you want for comfort, style, and long-term use.
Pros of Replacing a Bathtub
Replacing your bathtub has the advantage of lasting a long time. In fact, a well-made new tub can serve your home for decades without problems.
You can also pick whatever design style you want when replacing the tub. For example, you can replace your fiberglass tub with a bathtub made from high-end materials like copper, stone, or marble. This is also a chance to upgrade with spa-like features such as jets, heated surfaces, or ergonomic contours.
For homeowners creating a luxury retreat, choosing bathtub replacement instead of refinishing means you can install a custom bathtub that fits your vision and makes the tub a true centerpiece of the space.
Cons of Replacing a Bathtub
Bathtub replacement requires a larger investment of both money and time when compared to refinishing. A straightforward swap might cost a few thousand dollars, but complex projects with plumbing changes, tiling, and demolition can climb higher.
The process of replacing your tub can take days or weeks, depending on how well you plan for additional changes or alterations, which means your bathroom may be out of service during that time.
There’s also potential for hidden costs if problems are uncovered once the old tub is removed. For homeowners looking for a quick or budget-friendly update, bathtub replacement may feel disruptive compared to refinishing.
How To Decide if You Should Refinish or Replace a Bathtub
Because both refinishing and replacing a bathtub offer clear benefits, which is the right option for most homeowners? Asking the following questions can point you in the right direction:
-
How much damage does my tub have?
-
How long do I plan to stay in this home?
-
How quickly do I need the project finished?
-
How important is long-term durability to me?
-
Do I want a style upgrade or just a refresh?
-
What’s my budget?
There’s no one correct answer. The best choice depends on which of those factors matters most to you.
Skip Bathtub Refinishing and Choose a Custom Luxury Bathtub
When it comes to bathtub refinishing vs. replacement, both options have value. For homeowners planning a high-end remodel, replacement opens the door to custom designs and luxury materials that can turn an ordinary bathroom into a comfortable retreat.
At World CopperSmith, every bathtub is built to order, giving you the freedom to select the size, finish, and style that best suits your vision. A CopperSmith tub is a centerpiece that’s as functional as it is beautiful. Contact CopperSmith today to see how your investment will deliver lasting comfort, style, and pride in your space.